Mamdani Promised to Drop the Case on Day One. He Just Appealed It.
The big picture: New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing a $5.4 billion budget deficit, his ultimatum to force the state into taxing the rich has collapsed, and last night he broke a core campaign promise by appealing a housing case he swore he’d drop. Housing advocates are calling it a betrayal. Mamdani says the budget left him no choice.
Why it matters: This is the first major test of whether the progressive movement’s newest star can govern the way he campaigned. The answer so far: the budget spreadsheet is winning.
The ultimatum: Last month, Mamdani gave Albany two options. Either raise income taxes on New York’s 33,000 wealthiest residents and increase corporate taxes, or the city would hike property taxes by 9.5% on over three million homes and 100,000 commercial buildings. The New York Times estimated that would mean about $700 more per year for a typical homeowner. Governor Hochul was reportedly “greatly angered” and saw it as grandstanding.
The retreat: According to The New York Times, Mamdani has all but abandoned the property tax hike. Local leaders across the spectrum told him it was a nonstarter. A former colleague warned he’d be a one-term mayor. He quietly told lawmakers he was “highly unlikely” to pursue it. He’s now asking the state to raise taxes on corporations, unincorporated businesses, and high-value real estate instead, according to New York Focus.
The broken promise: Mamdani campaigned on dropping Eric Adams’ legal challenge to a City Council expansion of CityFHEPS, a rental assistance program covering 65,000+ households. The expansion would remove work requirements, raise income limits, and extend eligibility. The program currently costs $1.2 billion and is projected to hit $4.7 billion by 2030. Last night, Mamdani appealed the case to New York’s highest court.
A shelter operator told Gothamist: “Candidate Mamdani and Mayor-elect Mamdani promised to drop the appeal on day one. This is the classic political example of promise made, promise broken.”
What’s next: The state budget is due April 1st. Mamdani’s next budget presentation is May 1st. The city budget deadline is June 30th. Stock market volatility is complicating revenue projections. Mamdani tried to negotiate a CityFHEPS compromise but talks fell apart.
By the numbers:
$5.4 billion — NYC’s budget deficit
9.5% — the property tax hike Mamdani threatened, then abandoned
$700 — estimated annual increase per homeowner under that plan
65,000+ — households covered by CityFHEPS
$4.7 billion — projected CityFHEPS cost by 2030
33,000 — wealthiest New Yorkers targeted under the income tax proposal
The bottom line: Mamdani ran as the progressive who would tax the rich and expand housing. He’s now governing a city where the governor won’t help, the property tax threat collapsed, and the housing promise just turned into another court appeal. The deficit is real, the constraints are real, BUT the people who voted for him based on those promises are watching them dissolve, and “the budget made me do it” is a hard thing to campaign on next time.
The New York Times | The New York Times | Gothamist | City Limits | New York Focus
Thanks for reading! Comment your thoughts & reactions | Share to spread the word | Follow to stay in the loop