A Federal Prosecutor Just Backed Unsealing Jeffrey Epstein’s Alleged Suicide Note. The DOJ Admits It Has Never Seen It.
The big picture: A potential suicide note written by Jeffrey Epstein has been sealed from public view for years in a separate criminal case. The DOJ admits it has never seen it. Yesterday, a federal prosecutor backed a New York Times petition to unseal the note. A member of the House Oversight Committee is now demanding the DOJ explain why this note was never obtained, reviewed, or disclosed during the original investigations into Epstein’s death. Survivors and state legislators are pushing their own accountability efforts in parallel.
Why it matters: The Epstein case has become a stress test for whether the federal government can actually deliver accountability when the people implicated are wealthy and well-connected. Years after his death, the most basic questions about what happened, who else was involved, and what evidence still exists remain unanswered.
The note nobody has seen
The Times reported last week that a potential suicide note has been sealed from public view for years. It stems from an alleged suicide attempt in July 2019, just a few weeks before Epstein was found dead in his cell. At the time, Epstein was found unresponsive with red marks around his neck. He survived. His cellmate later said he discovered a note Epstein had written.
BUT here’s where it gets weird. Epstein himself reportedly told jail officials he wasn’t suicidal and that his cellmate had attacked him. He apparently never repeated that claim afterward. The cellmate denied attacking him. That’s its own tangle of unanswered questions before we even get to the note.
The note was sealed as part of the criminal case for the cellmate, who was later convicted of quadruple homicide but still maintains his innocence. Which means investigators looking into Epstein’s actual death may never have laid eyes on it. The note wasn’t included in the Epstein files. A DOJ spokesperson told the Times the agency has not seen it.
The legal push to unseal
The Times petitioned a New York federal judge to unseal the note. Yesterday, U.S. Attorney Jay Clayton wrote a letter supporting the petition, the argument being that there’s no reason for the courts to keep it sealed when the cellmate has already publicly disclosed parts of its contents.
In a previous interview, the cellmate described finding the note, claiming Epstein had written that the FBI had looked into him for months and found “nothing,” adding “What do you want me to do, cry about it.” It reportedly included a smiley face and a line about saying goodbye. Now it’s up to a judge to decide whether the public actually sees the document.
Congress steps in
Rep. Raja Krishnamoorthi of the House Oversight Committee sent a letter to the DOJ yesterday asking the agency to work with the judge to release the note, writing that it “must be immediately reviewed and publicly released to aid federal officials who are investigating Jeffrey Epstein and the circumstances around his death.”
He went further, saying the DOJ has yet to make any arrests beyond Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell, “despite the existence of millions of documents that suggest a vast network of sex traffickers, including many high-profile individuals at the center.” He’s now demanding the DOJ answer specific questions: Did it ever obtain, seek access to, or verify the note? Did it ever consider it relevant? Are there other known Epstein materials still missing from DOJ reviews?
These are pointed, specific questions. Either the DOJ knew about the note and chose not to pursue it, or it didn’t know, and has to explain why a piece of potential evidence was sitting unaccessed in a separate criminal file for years.
New York survivors push their own bill
Survivors of Epstein’s trafficking are pushing New York state to pass legislation that would criminalize behavior that benefits from and aids in trafficking. A lawyer for the group Enough Abuse put it this way, saying “Trafficking is not sustained by one single actor. It is not just Jeffrey Epstein. It is a network that includes financial backers, businesses and other intermediaries, who often escape accountability.”
The bill would also make it easier for Epstein’s victims to sue his estate by removing a policy that prevents recovering damages from a dead person’s estate. The State Senator who introduced it thanked the survivors and added: “The federal government may have turned its back on sex trafficking victims, but New York never will.” That line is doing some heavy lifting. State legislators publicly framing their bill as a response to federal failure on Epstein is not a small thing.
What’s coming next
House Oversight Democrats announced a hearing with Epstein survivors in Palm Beach on May 12. Members are also preparing a deposition with former Attorney General Pam Bondi and demanding it be videotaped and publicly released. So you have the Times pushing for the note, a federal prosecutor backing it, a House member demanding answers, New York moving on a bill, a federal hearing scheduled, and a high-profile deposition being prepared.
The question hanging over all of it is whether any of this actually produces accountability or just more documents and hearings that don’t lead anywhere.
By the numbers
2 - people ever charged in the Epstein case (Epstein and Maxwell)
0 - times the DOJ has reviewed the alleged suicide note, by its own admission
July 2019 - month of the alleged suicide attempt that produced the note
4 - homicides the cellmate who found the note has been convicted of
May 12 - date of the planned House Oversight hearing with survivors in Palm Beach
Millions - of documents Rep. Krishnamoorthi says suggest a wider trafficking network
The bottom line
A federal prosecutor and a sitting congressman now have to publicly push for the unsealing of a document the DOJ admits it has never seen. That alone tells you how broken the normal accountability process has become here. The people most invested in answers are still the survivors, doing the public work that the institutions tasked with this case haven’t.
Thanks for reading! Comment your thoughts & reactions | Share to spread the word | Follow to stay in the loop